To prove you’re not at fault in a car accident, you’ll need clear evidence, witness statements, and a strong understanding of Ohio traffic laws.
Whether you’re dealing with conflicting police reports, uncooperative insurance adjusters, or finger-pointing from the other party, proving you didn’t cause the accident is critical—especially if you’re facing insurance disputes, potential lawsuits, or damage to your driving record. In Ohio, fault impacts everything from insurance payouts to liability, and the burden of proof often falls on the driver who wants to clear their name.
If you were injured in an accident that was caused by someone else, contact our experienced car accident attorneys at Young, Reverman & Bolotin. We have over 200 years of combined experience in cases like yours, and we’ll help you prove you were not at fault.
Table of Contents
Proving the Other Driver Was At Fault
Proving you didn’t cause a car accident is usually going to involve proving the other driver was at fault. Your accident lawyer will help you establish fault, but here’s an overview of what the process entails.
1. Collect Evidence – Even After the Accident
Evidence is the backbone of any car accident claim. If you did not collect evidence immediately after the crash, however, you still have options:
- Revisit the Accident Scene: Take photographs of the area, including road conditions, signs, weather, skid marks, and damage patterns.
- Document Vehicle Damage: Capture clear images of all involved vehicles from multiple angles.
- Look for Physical Evidence: Broken glass, vehicle parts, or debris can help establish the cause of the crash.
2. Obtain Footage from Surveillance Cameras to Show You Were Not At Fault
Traffic cameras, dash cams, or security cameras from nearby businesses can provide crucial evidence. Act quickly to request footage from businesses before it is overwritten. This can give you visual proof of the accident and clearly show how it occurred.
3. Secure a Copy of the Police Report
A police report is a critical piece of evidence after a car accident. This document includes the officer’s account of the crash, witness statements, and any citations issued. Here’s how it can help you:
- If the officer’s report favors you, it strengthens your claim.
- Even if it favors the other driver, you can discuss the report with the investigating officer and provide any missing information that may alter their perspective.
4. Collect Witness Statements
Witnesses who saw the accident can provide firsthand accounts of what happened. Ask for their contact information and written or recorded statements. A neutral third-party perspective can be incredibly persuasive.
5. Know Your State’s Traffic Laws
Understanding local traffic laws can help you demonstrate that you were obeying the rules while the other driver was not. This is especially important in complex cases, such as left-turn accidents or rear-end collisions.
What to Do If the Police Report Is Not in Your Favor
If the police report wrongly suggests you were at fault, you can take steps to correct it. These might include:
- Contacting the Investigating Officer: Politely request a review and explain your side.
- Submitting Additional Evidence: Provide photos, video footage, and witness statements.
- Filing a Dispute: If necessary, you may be able to formally dispute the report.
When to Hire an Attorney to Prove You’re Not At Fault in a Car Accident
If the accident involves significant damage, severe injuries, or if the other driver denies fault, you should hire an experienced car accident attorney to handle your case. Additionally, if the insurance company refuses to pay, or tries to pressure you into accepting a low settlement offer, getting an attorney on your side can tip the scales in your favor. A car accident lawyer can help you gather evidence, negotiate with insurance companies, and, if necessary, represent you in court.
Proving Fault in Situations Where Fault Is Suggested
Some accident scenarios automatically suggest fault. If this is the case in your situation, don’t let your guard down. The other party’s insurance company will still try to misplace blame or minimize your injuries to reduce the payout you receive.
What situations might indicate that the other driver was at fault?
- Rear-End Collisions: The driver in the rear is usually considered at fault.
- Left-Turn Accidents: The driver making the left turn is typically at fault unless they can prove they had the right of way.
- Running a Red Light: Drivers who ignore traffic signals are almost always at fault.
Common Mistakes to Avoid When Trying to Prove You Are Not At Fault in a Car Accident
- Admitting Fault: Don’t apologize or admit guilt at the scene of an accident, even if you feel partly responsible.
- Failing to Document Damage: Take clear, comprehensive photos of both vehicles and the surrounding area.
- Ignoring Medical Attention: Even if you feel fine, get a medical evaluation and document your injuries. Some injuries take time to show symptoms.
Protect Your Rights After a Car Accident
If you were involved in an accident that wasn’t your fault, you don’t have to accept blame. By gathering evidence, understanding traffic laws, and working with an experienced attorney, you can protect your rights and secure the compensation you deserve.
Contact our experienced car accident attorneys at Young, Reverman & Bolotin today for a free consultation. Call 513-400-0000.
